Thick smash burgers with cheese are delicious in the double size. I will drive to Sanford for these burgers.
Fries are okay. Fried pickles were greasy and fried mushrooms were uneventful. If you're a big eater, skip the pickles and mushrooms and eat two doubles.
Nick Cangemi
-
October 28, 2024
Overall good experience. Would eat here again. I ordered the double smashburger w/ fries, and the burger was good sized, smashed but not too smashed, and I really liked all the cheese and burger sauce, and the bun was nice and soft. Unfortunately, they did burn my onions a bit (there was a pretty good sized burnt onion that I actually removed before taking my photo), and I personally think the fries were a bit overfried also. Ultimately I still ate and enjoyed everything, but it could have been better. Service is also very impersonal— you order on a touchscreen, and you get a text message when your food is ready, and then it’s just sitting there next to the touchscreen. There is zero human interaction. I don’t mind this, but I bet some people will not like it.
Brenda Wildes
-
July 13, 2025
Great food. And kid approved.
Mike D
-
November 10, 2024
Came at 1230 on a Sunday. Only 1 other group of people here in the whole place. The food was hot, and it came out quick. Everything was very salty, which, if you got the burger and NOT the fries it would be fine. Both together, and it's just too much. I didn't see a way to just do a burger, though. Also, there are no drinks for sale, so you have to go into the bar for even water.
It's new, and they will hopefully make some adjustments. It's probably better if you've been drinking or not worried about sodium. I may come back, but there are other places I would try first.
Rob P
-
September 05, 2024
I got a burger with fries and an order of fried pickles. The burger was decent, the fries were WAY too salty, and the fried pickles were also pretty salty and not worth $10. Overall I don't think I'll go out of my way for any of it again, but if you're already at Tuffy's, it's alright.
Thick smash burgers with cheese are delicious in the double size. I will drive to Sanford for these burgers. Fries are okay. Fried pickles were greasy and fried mushrooms were uneventful. If you're a big eater, skip the pickles and mushrooms and eat two doubles.
Overall good experience. Would eat here again. I ordered the double smashburger w/ fries, and the burger was good sized, smashed but not too smashed, and I really liked all the cheese and burger sauce, and the bun was nice and soft. Unfortunately, they did burn my onions a bit (there was a pretty good sized burnt onion that I actually removed before taking my photo), and I personally think the fries were a bit overfried also. Ultimately I still ate and enjoyed everything, but it could have been better. Service is also very impersonal— you order on a touchscreen, and you get a text message when your food is ready, and then it’s just sitting there next to the touchscreen. There is zero human interaction. I don’t mind this, but I bet some people will not like it.
Great food. And kid approved.
Came at 1230 on a Sunday. Only 1 other group of people here in the whole place. The food was hot, and it came out quick. Everything was very salty, which, if you got the burger and NOT the fries it would be fine. Both together, and it's just too much. I didn't see a way to just do a burger, though. Also, there are no drinks for sale, so you have to go into the bar for even water. It's new, and they will hopefully make some adjustments. It's probably better if you've been drinking or not worried about sodium. I may come back, but there are other places I would try first.
I got a burger with fries and an order of fried pickles. The burger was decent, the fries were WAY too salty, and the fried pickles were also pretty salty and not worth $10. Overall I don't think I'll go out of my way for any of it again, but if you're already at Tuffy's, it's alright.